Dynasty Statistical Edges: Week 12

Ryan McDowell

If you follow me on Twitter, you’ve probably noticed a series of tweets I share on a weekly basis regarding player and team defensive performances, all from a fantasy lens. I’m going to be sharing some of that same information with you here.

I use this each week as I am making my own lineup and waiver wire decisions and thought you might find this valuable as well.

Note: The scoring system used for this data is always PPR with four points for passing touchdowns.

Quarterbacks

Week 11 QB1s

RankPlayerFantasy Points Last Week
QB1Trevor Lawrence, JAX32.18
QB2Brock Purdy, SF26.72
QB3Justin Herbert, LAC25.70
QB4Lamar Jackson, BAL23.96
QB5Tommy DeVito, NYG22.54
QB6Josh Allen, BUF22.50
QB7Kyler Murray, ARI21.66
QB8Justin Fields, CHI21.16
QB9Jordan Love, GB20.88
QB10Jalen Hurts, PHI18.90
QB11Sam Howell, WAS17.70
QB12Tua Tagovailoa, MIA17.60

It took more than half the 2023 season but we finally got the breakthrough game from Trevor Lawrence. After tossing two scores and running for two more, Lawrence finished as the overall QB1 for the week. This was the first time this season Lawrence had exceeded 20 fantasy points. Last week, I pointed out what a great matchup the Commanders were for quarterbacks, but still couldn’t recommend rookie Tommy DeVito as a starting option. This was one of those cases where we should’ve continued to chase the matchup. DeVito shredded the Washington defense, throwing for nearly 250 yards along with three scores.

Season-Long QB1s

RankPlayerFantasy Points This Season
QB1Josh Allen, BUF247.10
QB2Jalen Hurts, PHI224.38
QB3Justin Herbert, LAC210.96
QB4Lamar Jackson, BAL207.14
QB5Sam Howell, WAS200.42
QB6Dak Prescott, DAL194.26
QB7CJ Stroud, HOU191.98
QB8Josh Dobbs, ARI191.54
QB9Brock Purdy, SF188.58
QB10Patrick Mahomes, KC188.36
QB11Tua Tagovailoa, MIA183.26
QB12Jared Goff, DET173.12

Week 11 brought almost no movement at all among the top twelve fantasy quarterbacks this season. Brock Purdy climbed two spots to the QB9, surprisingly just above Patrick Mahomes. Overall, this is the exact same dozen quarterbacks as last week.

Most QB1 Games This Season

QB1 GamesPlayers
9Jalen Hurts
8Josh Allen, Justin Herbert, Sam Howell
7
6CJ Stroud, Patrick Mahomes, Kirk Cousins, Baker Mayfield, Brock Purdy, Lamar Jackson
5Tua Tagovailoa, Russell Wilson, Josh Dobbs

Most QB1 Games Allowed

QB1 Games AllowedTeam DSTs
9WAS
8
7CHI
6JAX, LAC, TB
5ARI, ATL, CIN, DET, HOU, IND, NO, PHI, TEN
4BUF, DEN, LV, MIA, MIN, NYG
3DAL, GB, LAR, NE, NYJ, SEA, SF
2CAR, CLE, KC, PIT
1BAL

After getting destroyed by DeVito, the Commanders have now allowed nine QB1 games this year and are a weekly must-target regardless of the opponent. This week, that’s an easy choice as Dak Prescott and the Cowboys host the Commanders on Thanksgiving. Look for Prescott to get some fantasy teams off to strong starts this week. The Bears are next, giving up seven QB1 games on the season, though they are actually middle of the pack when it comes to fantasy points allowed to the position. Still, Vikings quarterback Josh Dobbs is a worthy fantasy starter this week. The Chargers have actually allowed the most fantasy points to opposing quarterbacks and this week face Lamar Jackson after losing Joey Bosa last week.

Other quarterbacks with solid matchups include CJ Stroud (vs. JAX), Gardner Minshew (vs. TB), and Josh Allen (vs. PHI.)

The Ravens remain the toughest matchup for opposing signal callers, having allowed just one QB1 game on the year and also limiting foes to just 15.5 fantasy points per game, the lowest in the league. That’s all bad news for Justin Herbert, though last week, Herbert had success against another strong pass defense in Green Bay.

The Panthers (vs. Will Levis), Browns (vs. Russell Wilson), Chiefs (vs. Aidan O’Connell), and Steelers (vs. Jake Browning) are all matchups to avoid this week. That should be easy to do given that list of quarterbacks.

prescott scaled

©tim heitman-usa today sports

Running Backs

Week 11 RB1s

RankPlayerFantasy Points Last Week
RB1Saquon Barkley, NYG30.00
RB2Jaylen Warren, PIT23.50
RB3Jahmyr Gibbs, DET21.50
RB4Christian McCaffrey, SF21.30
RB5Gus Edwards, BAL21.00
RB5 (Tie)Joe Mixon, CIN21.00
RB7Brian Robinson, WAS20.10
RB8Devin Singletary, HOU19.80
RB9D’Andre Swift, PHI19.70
RB10James Cook, BUF19.20
RB11Breece Hall, NYJ18.30
RB12Tony Pollard, DAL18.00

Thanks to a pair of receiving touchdowns, Saquon Barkley bounced back with his best performance of the season, tallying 30 fantasy points and an overall RB1 game. That’s Barkley’s first time scoring as the RB1 since Week One of last season. Much of the rest of the RB1 list looks like the previous list with backs Jaylen Warren, Jahmyr Gibbs, Gus Edwards, Brian Robinson and Devin Singletary all staying hot. Tony Pollard scored a touchdown for the first time since Week One and crept back into the RB1 range.

Season-Long RB1s

RankPlayerFantasy Points This Season
RB1Christian McCaffrey, SF241.90
RB2Raheem Mostert, MIA180.90
RB3Travis Etienne, JAX179.20
RB4Brian Robinson, WAS162.20
RB5Josh Jacobs, LV151.60
RB6Rachaad White, TB150.30
RB7D’Andre Swift, PHI149.70
RB8Jahmyr Gibbs, DET144.10
RB9Alvin Kamara, NO143.30
RB10Joe Mixon, CIN140.30
RB11Gus Edwards, BAL139.30
RB12Derrick Henry, TEN139.00

There was a ton of shakeup among the season-long running back scorers this week. Kenneth Walker, Bijan Robinson, Zack Moss, and Derrick Henry all fell off the list, replaced by Gibbs, Joe Mixon, Gus Edwards, and Breece Hall. Brian Robinson continued his surprising play and is now the RB4 on the year. Robinson has more receiving yards in the past two games than he had in the first 21 games of his career.

Most RB1 Games This Season

RB1 GamesPlayers
9Christian McCaffrey
8
7
6Travis Etienne, Alvin Kamara
5D’Andre Swift, Rachaad White, Breece Hall
4Kyren Williams, Raheem Mostert, Zack Moss, Derrick Henry, Josh Jacobs, Bijan Robinson, Austin Ekeler, Jahmyr Gibbs, Gus Edwards, Tony Pollard

Most RB1 Games Allowed

RB1/2 Games AllowedTeam DSTs
13ARI
12CAR, SEA
11CHI, LAC, LV, NYJ
10DEN, HOU, NE, NYG
9BUF, GB, IND, PIT, WAS
8CIN
7ATL, BAL, JAX, KC, LAR, MIA, MIN
6DAL, NO, SF, TEN
5CLE, DET, TB
4PHI

The Cardinals have given up 13 top-24 performances to running backs this season, the most in the league. That poor run defense could serve as a nice welcome back for Rams back Kyren Williams, who is expected to return to the lineup after a multiple-week absence. I would not hesitate to insert Williams back into my lineups immediately.

The Broncos (vs. Jerome Ford) and Panthers (vs. Derrick Henry) are the two teams allowing more than 27 fantasy points per game to opposing backfields. Other matchups to target this week include the Seahawks (vs. McCaffrey), Bears (vs. Alexander Mattison), Chargers (vs. Edwards), Raiders (vs. Isiah Pacheco), and Jets (vs. Raheem Mostert.)

The Eagles are the best rush defense in the league when it comes to fantasy scoring, giving up just four top-24 performances and the fewest fantasy points in the league. That does not bode well for James Cook as the Bills travel to Philly. The Browns (vs. Javonte Williams), Lions (vs. AJ Dillon), and Buccaneers (vs. Jonathan Taylor) are other difficult matchups for Week 12.

In addition to these teams, the other teams surrendering less than 17 fantasy points per game to opposing backfields are the Saints and Falcons and those NFC South foes face off this week. Bijan Robinson and Alvin Kamara are still fantasy starters, but expect lower fantasy scores than normal from that pair of top backs.

dlf promo 4for4 03

Wide Receivers

Week 11 WR1s

RankPlayerFantasy Points Last Week
WR1Calvin Ridley, JAX31.10
WR2Tyreek Hill, MIA30.60
WR3Tank Dell, HOU28.90
WR4Keenan Allen, LAC27.60
WR5Brandon Aiyuk, SF26.60
WR6DJ Moore, CHI22.60
WR7Amon-Ra St. Brown, DET21.70
WR8Davante Adams, LV21.20
WR9Khalil Shakir, BUF20.50
WR10DK Metcalf, SEA20.40
WR11Jayden Reed, GB19.20
WR12Puka Nacua, LAR18.70

Zay Jones was back for the Jaguars and that’s all it took for Calvin Ridley to get going. At least that’s been the narrative. Regardless of the reason, Ridley finally delivered after many frustrating weeks of poor play. Ridley caught a pair of touchdowns and claimed the overall WR1 spot. It was another week with a serious impact from rookie receivers and Tank Dell (WR3), Jayden Reed (WR11), and Puka Nacua (WR12) all delivered. With veteran Cooper Kupp dealing with another injury, Nacua should be in for a production boost in the coming weeks.

Season-Long WR1s

RankPlayerFantasy Points This Season
WR1Tyreek Hill, MIA254.90
WR2Keenan Allen, LAC232.66
WR3CeeDee Lamb, DAL214.70
WR4Stefon Diggs, BUF208.50
WR5AJ Brown, PHI205.30
WR6Amon-Ra St. Brown, DET192.10
WR7Ja’Marr Chase, CIN189.70
WR8DJ Moore, CHI182.00
WR9Puka Nacua, LAR177.80
WR10Adam Thielen, CAR175.20
WR11Mike Evans, TB168.00
WR12Davante Adams, LV162.10

The red-hot CeeDee Lamb is now up with the WR3 on the season and he and AJ Brown swapped positions this week. Veteran Davante Adams is back in the WR1 range, replacing Michael Pittman.

Most WR1 Games This Season

WR1 GamesPlayers
7Tyreek Hill
6Puka Nacua, Amon-Ra St. Brown, Stefon Diggs, AJ Brown, Keenan Allen
5CeeDee Lamb
4Tank Dell, Justin Jefferson, Ja’Marr Chase
3Jakobi Meyers, Adam Thielen, Rashid Shaheed, Chris Olave, Mike Evans, Tyler Lockett, Brandon Aiyuk, Calvin Ridley

Most WR1 Games Allowed

WR1/2 Games AllowedTeam DSTs
15PHI
14
13
12WAS
11JAX, LAC, NYG, TB
10BUF, CIN, NE, TEN
9ARI, BAL, GB, HOU, KC
8IND, MIN, SEA, SF
7CAR, CHI, LAR, LV, MIA, NO
6ATL, DAL, DET, NYJ, PIT
5
4CLE
3DEN

The Eagles might be tough against the run but continue to give it up to opposing receivers. Philadelphia has now allowed 15 top-24 fantasy games to receivers, three more than any other squad. It’s time for an eruption game from Bills receiver Stefon Diggs.

In addition to the Eagles, four other teams are giving up more than 40 fantasy points per game to enemy receivers. That includes the Chargers (vs. Zay Flowers), Commanders (vs. Lamb), Giants (vs. Demario Douglas), and Buccaneers (vs. Pittman.)

The Broncos and Browns are at the bottom of the receiver list, having allowed three and four top-24 fantasy games, respectively. This game also has the lowest over/under of the week, meaning fantasy managers should stay away from this matchup, when possible. Courtland Sutton and Amari Cooper have been solid fantasy starters this season but should be benched this week.

Other teams giving up less than 29 fantasy points per game include the Panthers (vs. DeAndre Hopkins), Packers (vs. Amon-Ra St. Brown), Cowboys (vs. Terry McLaurin), and Jets (vs. Tyreek Hill/Jaylen Waddle.)

Tight Ends

Week 11 TE1s

RankPlayerFantasy Points Last Week
TE1George Kittle, SF22.90
TE2Travis Kelce, KC15.40
TE3Josh Oliver, MIN14.70
TE4David Njoku, CLE12.60
TE5Stone Smartt, LAC12.10
TE6Dalton Schultz, HOU11.20
TE7Dalton Kincaid, BUF10.60
TE8Luke Schoonmaker, DAL10.30
TE9Donald Parham, LAC9.70
TE10TJ Hockenson, MIN9.50
TE11Trey McBride, ARI9.30
TE12Tanner Hudson, CIN8.90
TE12 (Tie)Cade Otton, TB8.90

The week started out on a sour note for the tight end position as Ravens’ star Mark Andrews suffered a season-ending injury last Thursday night. The list of tight ends that we could rely on each week just got shorter. That list does include Dalton Schultz, who has been on a hot streak after a slow start to the year, along with Dalton Kincaid and Trey McBride, who are in the midst of breakout seasons.

mcbride 2

© joe rondone/the republic / usa today network

Season-Long TE1s

RankPlayerFantasy Points This Season
TE1TJ Hockenson, MIN170.60
TE2Travis Kelce, KC156.10
TE3George Kittle, SF138.00
TE4Mark Andrews, BAL135.40
TE5Sam LaPorta, DET125.20
TE6Cole Kmet, CHI123.10
TE7Dalton Schultz, HOU11.20
TE8Dalton Kincaid, BUF104.60
TE9Evan Engram, JAX104.50
TE10Jake Ferguson, DAL101.60
TE11David Njoku, CLE98.30
TE12Logan Thomas, WAS98.10

George Kittle rode his overall TE1 week to help him climb from TE6 to TE3, while Kincaid jumped a couple of spots to TE8. Injured Dallas Goedert finally fell off the list, replaced by David Njoku.

Most TE1 Games This Season

TE1 GamesPlayers
9TJ Hockenson
8
7Evan Engram, Mark Andrews, Travis Kelce
6Dalton Schultz, Sam LaPorta, Jake Ferguson, Cole Kmet, David Njoku, George Kittle
5Dalton Kincaid

Most TE1 Games Allowed

TE1 Games AllowedTeam DSTs
7ATL, CIN, HOU
6ARI, CHI, DEN, NYJ, WAS
5BAL, IND, JAX, LAC, LAR, NO, PHI
4GB, LV, MIA, MIN, PIT, TB
3CAR, DET, KC, NE, NYG, SEA, SF
2DAL
1CLE, TEN
0BUF

The Falcons, Bengals, and Texans have each given up seven TE1 games. This week, that puts Juwan Johnson and Taysom Hill (vs. ATL), Pat Freiermuth (vs. CIN), and Evan Engram (vs. HOU) on the target list. Other teams that are matchups to chase at the tight end spot include the Broncos (vs. Njoku), Chargers (vs. Isaiah Likely), and the Eagles (vs. Kincaid.)

The Bills have still not allowed a TE1 game this year and with Goedert still out of action, that streak should continue. The Browns (vs. Adam Trautman) and Titans (vs. Tommy Tremble) have been tough against the tight end position as well and with this week’s matchups, I don’t see that changing. Finally, the Cowboys host Logan Thomas and the Commanders, so this might not be the week to use the veteran in fantasy lineups.

Finally, here is the chart summarizing how teams have fared against each position. I’ve also included the schedule for this week for reference.

picture1 2

ryan mcdowell
Latest posts by Ryan McDowell (see all)
Dynasty Statistical Edges: Week 12