Dynasty League Football


Dynasty Stock Market: Players tough to Value

The weekly Dynasty Stock Market features not only price checks, but provides player features, draft projections, trade values or a variety of other relevant topics each week to make sure we’re covering everything our premium content followers are demanding.

This week, we’re taking a look at four of the most challenging players to evaluate in dynasty leagues. There are a variety of reasons that could cause dynasty owners to struggle when placing value on specific players. A player’s age or team situation, their production or lack of production in relation to expectations, their health issues or off the field concerns are all factors that can muddy the water when determining value.

If you are happy with the current status of your team (are we ever?) then the value of your players may not really matter to you. But, if you are like most of us dynasty fanatics, you are always looking for trade possibilities to bolster your roster. Trade discussions are the primary time when value, and the process owners go through to place a current market value on players, becomes important.

Here, I take a look at some players that I find hard to decipher when considering their current value.

Peyton Manning, QB DEN

Denver quarterback Peyton Manning has had a long and successful career. In fact, over his thirteen years, he has yet to finish outside of the top ten among fantasy quarterbacks, which includes eight seasons in which he finished among the top three passers. Barring injury, this will be his fourteenth season to finish as a top ten quarterback and he’s currently among the top five. While the statistics can not be denied, the doubt and difficulty when placing a current value on Manning comes about when considering his age (36) and the neck injury that cost him the 2011 season.

As Manning was dealing with that serious injury a season ago, dynasty owners were quick to drop him from among the top five quarterback rankings to outside of the top twenty. While he has shown the ability to pick up where he left off, some are still not believers.

Some recent trades involving Manning include an even swap for veteran quarterback Tom Brady. Another owner packaged Manning with Patriots wide receiver Brandon Lloyd for Eagles running back LeSean McCoy.

These trades place a much higher value on Manning than I am willing to at this time. From what I have learned, as well as what Manning has displayed this season, it does seem that his neck injury is fully healed and should not be a concern. At the same time, he is still 36 years old and can’t have many more years of production like he is showing this season. If you are a Manning owner, but not contending, now is a great time to look to unload him. Obviously, take a look at the top teams in your league who are lacking a weekly high performing quarterback. Possibly target the Cam Newton or Michael Vick owners, if they have managed to stay near the top of the standings.

Jonathan Stewart, RB CAR

Panthers running back Jonathan Stewart has been a recent topic here at DLF, especially the past couple of weeks since he has taken over as the lead back in Carolina. Although Stewart has four full years of experience in the league, he is still only 25 years old and just signed a contract extension to remain in Carolina for the next six seasons.

Stewart has been a perennial disappointment for dynasty owners, especially those who have had him rostered the past five years, continuing to hope this will be the year he truly lives up to his potential. It all began in the last month of Stewart’s sophomore season for the Panthers when he totaled 470 yards and four touchdowns over the Panthers’ final three games. With Stewart’s success in college and first round pedigree, owners expectations were already high, but this late season performance cemented the hyped status we now know so well.

In the two and a half years since, Stewart has played well as one half of the Panthers running back by committee, alongside DeAngelo Williams. Stewart has averaged just under fifty yards per game during that time and has scored a total of six rushing touchdowns. Stewart’s relative lack of success has been attributed to coaching decisions, offensive schemes and of course, the presence of Williams. Whatever the reason, the numbers don’t lie. Stewart is a solid dynasty running back, but has been overvalued by many, including myself.

When the recent news broke that Stewart would see increased touches and could now be considered the starting running back, his value again shot up. While it has only been two weeks since this news, the results have been underwhelming. Stewart has 27 carries for 93 yards and no scores in two games as the starter.

Stewart is a challenge for me to evaluate as I try to weigh the immense talent he has displayed at times, along with the confusing decisions made by the coaching staff and general manager in Carolina. These factors together make Stewart a challenging case. Most of his owners have likely waited and waited for the payoff of their investment and are not likely to sell at a discount.

In recent trades, Stewart was moved for two future first round draft picks. He was also traded for injured Cardinals running back Ryan Williams and a future first round pick and finally he was moved for Packers wide receiver James Jones and a future second round rookie pick.

As you can see, his value is all over the board and most owners don’t seem willing to give up current value for him, but are more comfortable using risky draft picks in exchange for a risky, yet high upside, running back.

Mike Wallace, WR PIT

Following an explosive, but inconsistent rookie season in 2009, Steelers wide receiver Mike Wallace entrenched himself as a top dynasty wide receiver with back to back top ten seasons in 2010-2011, in which he averaged over 1,200 yards and eight touchdowns.

Also in 2011, we saw the emergence of another speedy wide receiver for Pittsburgh as Antonio Brown burst onto the scene. This off-season, while the Steelers and Wallace were battling over the details of a potential new contract, the Pittsburgh brass gave a huge new deal to Brown and left Wallace holding the (empty) bag.

This season, although Wallace is on pace for a career high of 78 catches, to go along with over 1,000 yards and ten touchdowns, he has again been inconsistent. Add to that the unknown future Wallace has to look forward to this off-season. We all have seen that quarterback Ben Roethlisberger is not afraid to chuck the ball down the field for Wallace and Brown. The uncertainty about where Wallace will play in 2013 clouds his value and makes him a risk for dynasty owners to acquire at this time.

Recent trades involving Wallace show us that his value has slipped from where it was a year ago at this time. One owner gave up Wallace along with tight end Vernon Davis for Patriots tight end Rob Gronkowski. A second trade was an even swap of Wallace for running back CJ Spiller.

Wallace’s fall down the ranks can ultimately be attributed to his holdout last offseason, but the truth is that he was likely being overranked when he was placed among the top eight wide receivers by many dynasty owners.

Tony Gonzalez, TE ATL

Falcons tight end Tony Gonzalez is one of the best and most reliable players of all time. Excluding his rookie season of 1997, he has never finished outside of the top ten among fantasy tight ends. He has also never missed more than one game in any season, missing only two games his entire career.

The ageless one is at it again this season and currently ranks as the TE4. Even though he is competing for targets with two top wide receivers (Roddy White and Julio Jones), he is still on pace for 100 catches and nearly 1,000 yards, as well as eight touchdowns.

Of the players mentioned so far, Gonzalez is the easiest player to identify the cause of our troubles. His age of 36, along with multiple reports that this will be his final season in the NFL have greatly affected his value. In fact, in the off-season, he was being traded for future third round picks, which is dirt cheap. There would have been no discussion had he come out and played like a typical 36 year old. Instead, he is one of the top tight ends in the game yet again and contending owners are scrambling to acquire a reliable tight end.

Trading for Gonzalez at this point is a 100% “win now” move. There is a very good chance retires at the conclusion of this season and he would obviously have no value at that point. However, if you are a contending team and you have a gaping hole at tight end, Gonzalez could be a very valuable patch that might make all the difference in your season.

For teams out of the playoff race, he is the top sell candidate in fantasy. Take anything you can get for him.

This discrepancy in how Gonzalez is valued by different owners has caused there to be very few trades involving him recently. He was moved for Texans running back Ben Tate. Another trade I actually made netted me Lions tight end Brandon Pettigrew and a future second round pick – both of those trades represent very good value for the future Hall of Famer.

Follow @RyanMc23 on Twitter.

Ryan McDowell
Latest posts by Ryan McDowell (see all)
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
9 years ago

Wallace has only had 1 bad game. In PPR he’s scored double digits in every other game. I wouldn’t call that inconsistent. If someone traded him for Spiller straight up, I’d say Wallace’s value is quite high still.

9 years ago

What do people think about Mendenhall going forward?

Chuck Gordon
Reply to  althomasonjr
9 years ago

Mendenhall is also tough to value. He is in a contract year and he needs to get back on the field. The Steeler backfield is now a mess with Dwyer and Redmen coming off solid games. Mendenhall may not even be in a Steelers uniform next year, and if that’s the case, his landing spot will largely dictate his value. I’d say he’s a buy low and hold situation until his situation shakes out.

Reply to  Chuck Gordon
9 years ago

Thanks, I’m actually an owner going through a complete rebuild. Ive been offered 2 back end firsts and 2 back end seconds (8-12 range) one this year and one next year. Value seems fair but Id hate to see Mendenhall regain form or go to a team like Indianapolis. I also already have 2 first rounders this year including likely the first overall. I’m leaning towards rejecting

Reply to  Ryan McDowell
9 years ago

Interesting. You guys at DLF always seem to value draft picks more than anyone else.
However I see it as: Mendy is 25 and has had 3 top 15 fantasy seasons. Nobody would trade him for a Ronnie Hillman and Jaquizz Rodgers Package would they? (Two backend first examples)

Cyrus Miller
Reply to  Ryan McDowell
9 years ago

I own Mendy in several dynasties. I even gave up a 1st and a 3rd for him preseason this year, expecting him to get healthy and be the guy.

I’m not sure whether I like him in PIT. With their recent running success, I think he could really do well, but I could also see him go to a new team and be the main guy. Prior to this year, I thought his biggest issue was that the Oline wasn’t opening up big holes for him.

If I were offered two firsts and two seconds, I would take it. I would gamble on getting at least one playmaker who is better than Mendenhall out of it.

The one thing I would caution is this– don’t go chasing RB’s with those picks. The trick is to give up other value, or trade the picks, for a RB. (And if you really really need RB, don’t trade Mendy)

Getting value from a late first or second round pick requires patience and taking BPA. Usually, the RB’s are picked over and are not BPA. I like to take the best at a different position, so if a top LB (like Kuechly) or a WR I really like (Wright this past year, Cobb the year before) is there at the end of the first, I take them. If you chase after RB, you end up wasting a lot of those picks.

(That said, I got Demarco Murray in the 2nd round)

9 years ago

With Arod as my QB I made the following trade RG3,Antonio Brown and a 2013 1rst rd pick 7-10 range for Calvin Johnson. Can you evaluate how I did?

Matt Warton
Reply to  ziggy19
9 years ago

I would say that you overpaid. From everything that I have seen and read RG3’s trade value is SKY HIGH. I would think that the deal could have been down as a straight swap RG3 for Megatron.

Cyrus Miller
Reply to  ziggy19
9 years ago

I think that is fair value for Calvin, and it all depends on what the Calvin owner expects to get. I think Calvin is the best WR in the NFL right now and while he has had a down year, it could easily turn around in the second half.

Therefore, the other owner basically has a monopoly. You could have offered RG3 and Antonio Brown for another top WR like Cruz or Julio, but you wouldn’t be getting Calvin.

On the one hand, I agree with Matt Warton that the value of RG3 is huge, so you could have shopped around for another top WR without giving up the 1st. However, I don’t think you overpaid (you just missed an opportunity to pay less for another WR), and I don’t know of anyone who would give up Calvin for RG3 straight up in any of my leagues.

Tyler Shelton
9 years ago

Dynasty, 12 team 30 roster spots. My current QB’s are Peyton, Luck, Sanchez, and Nick Foles (PHI).

I am thinking of offering Peyton and a #2 for Newton and a #3. I am currently tied for 2nd to last in the standings but could make the playoffs as the last wildcard by total points scored. The other guy is 2nd overall in the standings.

What do you think of this trade? If I had to, is my #1 and Peyton worth a trade for just Newton?

To Top