2025 Post-Draft OFF/IDP Combined Rookie Mock Draft: Part One

Editor's Note: This is part one of a combined IDP and skill position players rookie mock draft going five rounds deep, with commentary on every pick. Part one will cover the first two rounds, which plays out much like an offense-only mock draft.  We'll bring you part two on Wednesday, which will wrap up the last three rounds, featuring a high percentage of IDP picks. 

The 2025 NFL Draft in Green Bay, Wisconsin has concluded. We have helped you out with our rankings and mock drafts for dynasty leagues up to this point. I recently released my two-round rookie IDP dynasty draft. But now I’m giving you an offense and defense combined dynasty rookie draft.

In this draft, I am going to select players based on my overall rankings of rookies and where I would select them if I were choosing at each draft position. If I’m higher or lower than consensus on a player, I will point that out.

I am giving you a combined offense and defense five-round dynasty rookie draft. This draft assumes a 12-team league with a superflex position, one point per reception, and a tight end premium of .5 points. On defense, I’m assuming you are starting five positions: DT, DE, LB, S, and CB. We are assuming a tackle-heavy system with IDP 1-2-3 scoring for big plays and takeaways.

The 2025 NFL Draft was the opposite of the previous year, with a ton of defensive talent being selected in the first three rounds of the draft. There were a lot of potential stars drafted at the defensive line and edge rusher positions, while off-ball linebacker and safety were two positions that lacked depth, but there is some talent you will want to keep on your radar for upcoming drafts.

Just like the defensive players, this draft’s offensive players had some major talent at the top of the draft, but might end up being better known for how deep the class is, especially at the running back and tight end positions. Quarterback and wide receiver were a bit slim, but there are some nice values later in drafts.

I’m making these picks on my overall rankings, but be sure to make adjustments for your specific league scoring and for any team needs you might have. Let’s get to it.

Round One

1.01: Travis Hunter, WR/CB JAC

Hunter was my WR1 entering the draft and arguably the best overall player in the draft. He was picked second by Jacksonville after trading up to get him. The Jaguars’ new regime immediately made it clear that they plan to play Hunter as a full-time wide receiver, but Hunter expressed that he expects to play cornerback as well. The Jaguars hired an offensive-minded head coach in Liam Coen, who now has Hunter to pair with second-year receiver Brian Thomas Jr. Quarterback Trevor Lawrence has the two most talented players he has ever played with now on the outside. Lawrence could be headed for a career year. Now add in the fact that Hunter can rack up some additional points on defense and can be started in a CB or DB slot with WR2 upside, and it’s hard not to take him over running back Ashton Jeanty. I’m all in on Hunter as long as your league allows him to be started in a defensive spot. If he can only be an offensive starter in your league, he drops behind Jeanty for me, but he should still be selected in the top two.

1.02: Ashton Jeanty, RB LV

In all other formats Jeanty is the clear-cut pick at 1.01. Whoever lands him at 1.02 here will be extremely happy. The Raiders hired Pete Carroll as head coach and Chip Kelly as offensive coordinator. Add that to Jeanty being picked sixth overall, and it should mean a ton of touches for Jeanty. With Las Vegas adding Geno Smith to the mix at quarterback, this offense is ready to take a massive leap in 2025. Jeanty should be considered a top-five fantasy RB as a rookie and for years to come.

1.03: Omarion Hampton, RB LAC

The Chargers have a run-first approach with head coach Jim Harbaugh and offensive coordinator Greg Roman. Hampton was a first-round pick and now lands in a premium spot. He is a versatile running back who will get behind an improved offensive line. Quarterback Justin Herbert has shown he can sling it, which should help keep defenses honest and from constantly stacking the box. Hampton has huge upside.

1.04: Cam Ward, QB TEN

Ward was the first pick in the NFL Draft. What is pushing him down from being the 1.01 in fantasy? There are some absolute studs at premium positions in front of him. Also, the Titans' lack of recent success at quarterback, and on offense in general, doesn’t necessarily inspire confidence in fantasy managers' minds. In a weak QB class, Ward stands out as the top dog. He should be locked in as the starter from Day One. His arm talent is undeniable, and his ability to move around and evade defenders in the pocket is something he is going to need to rely upon early on in his career. Ward and the Titans are both likely to struggle in 2025, but it is rare that you get the top quarterback in the class with the fourth pick. Take Ward and hope that Tennessee can figure out how to build around him.

1.05: Tetairoa McMillan, WR CAR

McMillan had seen some prospect fatigue leading up to the draft, but after being selected eighth by the Panthers, that should dissipate. His blend of size, athleticism, hands, and YAC ability should make him Carolina’s WR1 from the day he steps onto the Panthers’ facilities. He is rare as a true X receiver in today’s NFL. Quarterback Bryce Young should feed McMillan 150+ targets this season. Even if the Panthers continue to struggle, the offense should be improved, and they should be playing from behind quite a bit. McMillan should hit the ground running for fantasy football managers.

1.06: TreVeyon Henderson, RB NE

Henderson was my RB3 entering the draft. He got fantastic draft capital going in the early second round to the Patriots. While drafting a New England running back has been the thing of fantasy nightmares in the past, Bill Belichick is gone. Rhomandre Stevenson is still there, but he is quickly wearing out his welcome with his ball control issues. That is something Henderson doesn’t have. He didn’t fumble at all during his time at Ohio State. He is probably the best pass-blocking RB in the class and is a very capable receiver out of the backfield. Henderson should immediately take over the third-down RB role, and it will only be a matter of time before his versatility and game-breaking abilities lead him to grab the full-time RB1 slot in the Patriots’ backfield.

1.07: Quinshon Judkins, RB CLE

Judkins racked up three straight 1,000-yard seasons in college with a total of 50 touchdowns. He is a hard runner with a nose for the end zone. He showed his athleticism at the combine running a 4.48 40-yard dash at 6-0, 220 pounds. He is the perfect replacement for former Browns running back Nick Chubb. Cleveland needs to win with defense and the running game with their issues at quarterback. Judkins should see a load of carries this season and in the future.

1:08: Tyler Warren, TE IND

Warren is an interesting player. He didn’t break out until his senior season, but he is coming from Tight End U. Penn State has consistently produced quality tight ends that have succeeded in the NFL. Warren lands in a precarious spot in Indianapolis. The Colts were desperate for a tight end in their offense the last couple of seasons, but the lack of development by Quarterback Anthony Richardson has some people worried. The QB situation is disconcerting, but Warren’s ability to do a little bit of everything for the Nittany Lions’ less than spectacular offense should prove that he can overcome the Colts’ QB woes. I have seen him slip in some drafts lately to the end of the first round, but I’m happy to grab him anywhere between 1.08-1.12.