Dynasty League Football


Underrated in Dynasty: Part Three


Well, you’ve come this far, so you might as well take the full leap of faith. Part One and Part Two of this series were made of up players who, while undervalued,  still have some value, at least in terms of ADP. This group will consist of players who just about everyone has given up on, including myself. From my experiences in the last seven years of dynasty leagues, I’ve learned to never be surprised if, and or when the ‘light turns on’ for a player. Some are stuck with injures and never get a chance, some need multiple years to get a feel for the NFL and some are battling demons (things in their personal life) we have no clue about. These are players who can be had extremely cheap in the 15th-25th rounds of a start-up dynasty draft, or even potentially players sitting on a waiver wire in leagues you’re already in. These are the types of players who you grab in bunches and hope one or two hit. They can sit at the end of your roster and chill out while the rest of the players do the heavy lifting. The goal of late round drafting should be to find players who have a chance for opportunity, or at one point were highly coveted.

First, before I ask you to take the ‘acquire players everyone has given up on’ plunge, I’m going to give you some background in why I believe in this.

Around five years ago, I started delving into the waiver wire and end of the roster players, trying to figure out some way of ‘predicting’ a breakout, or at the very least, finding some value for nothing. I won’t say I found the holy trinity, but I’ve found a way to hedge certain types of players, which will at least increase your odds of hitting it big.

The ‘certain type of player’ is pretty simple. I look for the former first or second round NFL Draft pick – it’s as simple as that.

Some of this is preference, as there will be quite a few options sitting there for you in rounds 15-20 (generally), but the most important part is that you have at least 4-5 of them (preferably 6-8). I’m not saying you can’t grab other players off the grid, but I haven’t found a successful way to hit consistently on players drafted in lower rounds. I know it’s hard to trust the NFL and the way they draft, but, in general, the players picked in the higher rounds have more ‘talent’ (bleh, you know what I mean) and even if they don’t, they will be given many more chances to ‘get it’ than lower drafted players – it’s not rocket science.

If my rambling’s weren’t clear, to be safe, I’m giving you some examples from the past. I did a somewhat broad ADP guess based off dynasty mocks I could find on Myfantasyleague.com and other random drafts to find some previous first or second round picks who broke out later than expected.

Vernon Davis, TE SF

Daft pick: 1st round, pick 6
Breakout Year: 4th (2009)
Dynasty ADP Before: 16th-17th
Dynasty ADP After:  4th-6th

Knowshon Moreno, RB MIA

Draft Pick: 1st round, pick 12
Breakout Year: 5th (2013)
Dynasty ADP Before: 17th-20th
Dynasty ADP After: 8th-10th

Jordy Nelson, WR GB

Draft Pick: 2nd round, pick 5 (#36 overall)
Breakout year: 4th year (2011)
Dynasty ADP Before: 19th-21st
Dynasty ADP After: 2nd-3rd

Vincent Jackson (2008), Roddy White (2007) and Thomas Jones (2004) are all great examples as well, though it’s much more difficult to find specific ADP data from that many years ago. Regardless, those who have played in dynasty leagues for long enough remember patiently waiting or giving up on that set of players. The moral of this story is pretty simple – these things do happen and generally we see one previously highly drafted player surprisingly break out each season. Anything you can do to increase your odds of hitting on one of these players is a good idea. With all that being said, let’s take a look at this island of misfit high picks.


Jake Locker, TEN (4th year)


Donald Brown, SD (6th year)
Mark Ingram, NO (4th year)
Mikel Leshoure, DET (4th year)


Stephen Hill, NYJ (3rd year)
Jon Baldwin  SF (4th year)
AJ Jenkins, KC (3rd year)
Brian Quick, STL (3rd year)


Jermaine Gresham, CIN (5th year)
Coby Fleener, IND (3rd year)

There are more players who I left off the list, some for obvious reasons. I didn’t feel the need to put players like Titus Young, Jahvid Best or Blaine Gabbert on here, as their NFL careers are most certainly either over or close to it. Not an exciting list, is it? I don’t have any nice, encouraging things to say, either. However, it’s time to trust the process. Pull up your bootstraps and prepare for battle, or sit in your computer chair, whichever.

Once again, I want to put emphasis on the fact the majority of these players are set to become nothing more than waiver wire fodder. It’s important to not get your hopes high for all of them – the goal is to strike it rich on one player.

Another scenario that’s worth noting is the idea of finding one or two players who provide week-to-week support . A good example of this in the past would be Darius Heyward-Bey (7th pick in the 2009 draft).  Heyward-Bey subtly broke out in the second half of 2011 and became a solid WR3 for a bit. He would’ve been found on your waiver wire. Again, you have something for nothing. I’d encourage everyone to take a good look at your waiver wire at this point in time and see if there are some formerly highly regarded players turned busts at this moment of time and see if you have an extra roster spot or two – just don’t roster anyone you’re going to need to cut when your rookie draft starts. If that’s the case, you’ve just turned over a stone for your league mates.

Detach yourself from players, fall in love with value.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
do it for johnny
7 years ago

Locker, Ingram only ones with even a shot and chances are bad for both of them. Jets just about done with Hill…kid just can not catch which is kind of a problem if you are a WR.

Reply to  do it for johnny
7 years ago

they’re all imperfect prospects/players. that’s why they’re available so late in drafts. as I mentioned, I don’t even have good things to say about most. but , they do fit into that threshold I talked about, some of these guys do develop into things that shock us, it happens every year

michael bellace
7 years ago

Good idea here Russell as this is a perfect article for my present situation. First, I want to say that there are 2 guys I think still have a decent chance, Brown & Locker. Brown gave some flashes of it in Indy but now is in a crowded committee, so who knows, maybe if Mathews goes down we’ll see? Locker will be healthy and some better pieces to work with so I can see a possibility there. Which brings me to the guy in question for me, Ingram? I’ve been offered Ingram & Sproles for Chris Johnson. I like 50% of the deal, so is the Ingram side worth the gamble or should I hold onto CJ747?

Reply to  michael bellace
7 years ago

it’s only worth it if you can get a ton of these guys, not one. the odds you buy ONE of these guys and hit is not likely. as I mentioned in the article, you want to grab as many as you can to increase your odds.

7 years ago

I like the Leshoure suggestion. He looked good the last time he saw the field, probably finds a new team in 2015. I also think Ingram is a buy. Khiry has made him cheap, and with Sproles, Ivory and Pierre gone, it’s now or never. He also will probably find a new setting in 2015

michael bellace
Reply to  AP
7 years ago

FYI/Pierre Thomas got resigned. So they’ve got Thomas, Ingram, Robinson & Cadet.

7 years ago

Great article! I recently picked both Leshore and Hill in the last round of a start up draft for this exact reason. If they hit this year then I got great value but if they don’t they will be released next year for a rookie. Either way I think they were great picks.

Ravens Fan
7 years ago

St Hill and Fleener are players I drafted as rookies and have held onto. Still waiting for their breakthroughs, although Fleener is a viable te2 in a 14 team league. I have three picks in the top 23 in this rookie draft. Hill is on my chopping block along w Ace sanders who showed flashes last year. Not sure what to do with either one of them. Do I give up on them them to make space for this years stellar wr class. I have rostered Hill for two years and it would kill me to see him finally breakout after I waive him. Who has a greater probability of being a fantasy contributor over his career, the rookie wr or the year three wr , ie Hill?

7 years ago

Really enjoying this series.

Toby Gerhart comes to mind in respect to this philosophy, as he was a 2nd rounder that sort of became WW material and is now seeing a bump in value.

But wondering why Ryan Williams: Round 2, 4th Year, is not being included. He was lumped with Leshoure at his draft slot way back when. I’m not a believer of Williams and think hes finished, but just wondering if he would need inclusion here? Another player – R.Hillman doesnt count I believe, since he was a 3rd rounder – drafted at the 4th pick in the 3rd round by DEN.

Seems, in essense, this throws cold water on some of the players picked in the latter rounds that are being slightly hyped up early this year? Like Jerrel Jernigan: Round 4, 4th Year, Andrew Hawkins: Undrafted, 4th Year, etc. but assume there’s always exceptions.

Robinson, Adrien: Round 4, 3rd Year

russell clay
Reply to  SJ
7 years ago

wow! looks like you may have hit on Gerhart!

I obviously missed him , but if you ended up grabbing him in a startup before he was a free agent signing, you already struck gold

To Top